Cake Flavors

Cake, Cake and More Cake!

When choosing a wedding cake flavor, it's important to pick something that will appeal to a variety of tastes, while also fitting the overall theme and vibe of your celebration. That said, this is your special day, and you absolutely deserve a stunning cake that tastes as amazing as it looks. All Butter Me Up cakes are frosted with silky Swiss meringue buttercream. In addition, all fillings and buttercreams are made 100% from scratch, to order, using high quality, fresh ingredients for the best possible flavor and do not contain any preservatives.

CARROT CAKE
Carrot layers with toasted pecans and rum soaked raisins with vanilla bean buttercream.

CARAMEL BLISS CAKE
Vanilla layers with salted caramel buttercream and caramel filling

CHOCOLATE OREO CAKE
Chocolate mocha layers with crushed Oreo buttercream

CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CAKE
Chocolate mocha layers with peanut butter buttercream and candied peanuts

COCONUT CANDY BAR CAKE
Coconut layers with chewy shreds of coconut and chocolate buttercream

DOUBLE CHOCOLATE CAKE
Chocolate mocha layers with dark chocolate ganache and chocolate buttercream

FUN FUNFETTI CAKE
Funfetti layers with silky vanilla buttercream

LEMON MERINGUE CAKE
Vanilla layers with fresh lemon curd and lemon buttercream

S’MORE CAKE
S’more layers with marshmallow meringue and chocolate buttercream

SPICE CAKE
Infused spice layers with vanilla buttercream

TROPICAL PARADISE CAKE
Coconut layers with coconut butter buttercream

CLASSIC VANILLA CAKE
Vanilla layers with silky vanilla buttercream

Cake Decorating!

The cake decoration can make a huge impact on the overall aesthetic. Some options to consider are:

  • Buttercream Flowers: Beautifully handcrafted flowers.

  • Cake Toppers: These could be personalized with figurines, monograms, or themed decorations that represent the couple’s interests or style.

  • Fresh Flowers: Elegant and natural, they can be incorporated into any cake style, from modern to rustic.

  • Fresh Fruit: Adds natural beauty and a burst of flavor.

  • Edible Gold: Metallic accents can add a luxurious touch to the cake.

  • Dried Flowers & Herbs: Natural and aesthetically pleasing.